Don’t get misled by the facts

There’s a piece in the latest Local Government Association (LGA) First magazine, that could easily prove extremely misleading to elected members, given that it suggests that, despite all the budget cuts and threats to services, councils’ are doing okay.

The article is actually extracted from something written Neil Wholey, Head of Research and Customer Insight at Westminster City Council – whatever that is, the job, not the council. Whilst the piece may not be inaccurate in any way, the author obviously knows his stuff and the facts are the facts, it’s certainly likely to offer a misleading picture to those who, when reading it, don’t bother to separate out the elements that make up a council.

As a LGA publication, it’s difficult not to see the magazine as primarily a vehicle for communicating with elected members, as opposed to the professionals and this where the misleading bit begins.  The article called, Residents’ Views, tells the reader that, despite all the hardships being visited on taxpayers by government, local government’s reputation is doing surprisingly well.

I’ve no reason to doubt what the author is saying when it comes to public opinion, especially if the questions were asked in a way that avoids any reference to the politics of the council.  The problem comes when an elected member reads this and either misses, or completely ignores, the basis on which the questions were asked.  The public are expressing a view of their experience of the council, not the councillors.

I wonder what the answer would have been if, instead of asking, ‘overall do you think the council is providing good services in your area?’ they had asked, ‘how well do you think the (insert political group name as appropriate) are running your local council?’.  By inserting politics into the question, you immediately invite a biased response, based on the politics of the person being asked the question. Taken a step further, even if the council is performing well, the fact that it is controlled by one, or other of the political parties, will be far more influential when it comes to an election, than any public satisfaction survey, however rosy a picture it paints.

 

My point is, that any politician reading this and taking it at face value, could be in danger of deluding themselves in to thinking that taxpayer satisfaction with ‘the council’, is the same as satisfaction with ‘the councillors’.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Don’t get misled by the facts

  1. Good stuff Roger. You have 20:20 vision where others wear blinkers!
    Cutting senior management is an easy thing to do and I agree that once they are gone it seems to have been painless and services continue to run efficiently by the staff left behind. The problem councils will face is like a ticking time bomb. All of those maligned staff were engaged in improvement and planning for the future. Junior and inexperienced staff can maintain services for a while because they have inherited well managed services but sadly they are unable to plan effectively for future change. Council Members congratulate themselves on a job well done in removing staff they considered surplus to requirement but one day they will be in for a huge shock and a massive bill!

    Like

  2. Agreed. Ridiculous as it seems, we are currently in the honeymoon period for the cuts. It’s a bit like saying: Oh look, we’ve removed one of the 4 legs on our stool and as long as we sit off to one side of it, everything’s fine, I don’t know what all the fuss was about. Oh and by the way, we got a really good price for the unwanted leg, because one of our neighbours needed one for some reason.

    Unfortunately, at some point you might need to shift position on your stool because the one you’re in has become bloody uncomfortable and you’re getting a very sore bum. The problem is, any shifting around causes the stool to become very wobbly, especially if you try to move back towards the most comfortable bit – the centre. Also, if something happens behind you and you need to turn around to deal with it, you will get a huge crick in your neck, or even fall off of your 3 legged stool altogether. Now you’re the one desperately looking around to see if anybody’s got a leg to spare. Of course in the meantime, prices of legs have gone up and all that cash you made by selling yours, is now needed, plus a good deal more.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s